Oh, I see! moments
Travel Cultures Language

Remembering D-Day

by Meredith Mullins on June 2, 2014

[nopinit]

Robert Capa's photograph of a single soldier coming ashore during the Omaha Beach D-Day invasion on the longest day where life's choices made a difference. (Photo © Robert Capa/International Center of Photography/Magnum Photos)

D-Day Invasion at Omaha Beach in Normandy
© Robert Capa/International Center of Photography/Magnum Photos

Life’s Choices on “The Longest Day”

The grainy black-and-white image of a soldier fighting a surging sea to get ashore, amidst the obstacles and debris of battle, is one of the iconic images of the D-Day invasion.

It is made with the camera so close we can touch the moment. Its sheer power is a dramatic reminder of the essence of war . . . and life’s choices that bring us to the midst of such a battle.

It was June 6, 1944—a day of triumph, courage, and unimaginable loss.

The Normandy invasion by the Allied forces was a turning point of World War II. For the world and for the photographers and correspondents bringing the news to the world, it was the most important day of the war.

As General Eisenhower told his troops, “The eyes of the world are upon you.”

The journalists, in turn, felt intense pressure to document this significant event in the most raw, real, and memorable way possible.

Omaha Beach in Normandy in peaceful times, the site of the D-Day invasion on the longest day, where life's choices made a difference (Photo © Meredith Mullins)

Omaha Beach in Normandy today . . . hauntingly peaceful
© Meredith Mullins

Getting the Picture

Even though 70 years have passed since the day, John Morris remembers every moment vividly.

At the time, he was the picture editor at the London office of Life Magazine, responsible for several war correspondents, including the famous and infamous Robert Capa (the kind of infamy that made Capa write on his helmet: “Property of Robert Capa, great war correspondent and lover”).

Of the four spots allotted to press photographers to land with the first wave of the American infantry, Life managed to get two spots—assigned to veterans Bob Landry and Capa.

War correspondent working in France, after the D-Day invasion, where life's choices made a difference (Photo © John Morris/Contact Images Press)

War correspondents worked wherever and however they could.
Photo taken by Life Picture Editor John Morris in the month following the D-Day invasion.
© John G. Morris/Contact Press Images

Legendary Photographs

Capa often said, “If your photo isn’t good enough, you’re not close enough.” These weren’t just words. He lived this creed, often putting his life on the line.

In his memoir, he explained, “The war correspondent has his stake—his life—in his own hands, and he can put it on this horse or that horse, or he can put it back in his pocket at the very last minute. I’m a gambler.”

Whether he should be called brave, fearless, adrenaline-addicted, or just plain insane, Capa decided to go ashore with the first wave of infantry. No other photographer took this risk.

With the Germans well-positioned and waiting on the beach cliffs, the odds for survival were not in Capa’s favor. But he knew he would get the best photos.

Barbed wire at Omaha Beach in Normandy, site of the D-Day invasion and the longest day, where Life's choices made a difference (Photo by David hughes/iStock)

D-Day at Omaha Beach, a turning point in WW II
© David Hughes/iStock

D-Day at Omaha Beach

After a long night of waiting (a poker game taking their mind off what was to come at dawn), the men of the U.S.S. Samuel Chase, including Capa, were called on deck and the landing barges were deployed.

The barges couldn’t get all the way to the beach, so Capa started his photo sequence as the men jumped into the cold sea. The coastline in the background was filled with smoke from rockets and machine gun fire. The water was littered with steel barricades, and, soon enough, bodies.

Capa was capturing this action when the barge boatswain kicked him in the rear, thinking Capa was hesitating about leaving the barge. Into the cold water he went . . . and into the line of fire.

Serious Business

“I felt a new kind of fear,” Capa admitted in his memoir. He kept repeating his mantra from his time photographing the Spanish Civil War. “Es una cosa muy seria.” This is serious business.

He continued to photograph, even turning his back to the Germans to capture the historic image of the incoming soldier.

Finally, after an eternity (90 minutes in real time), he spotted a landing barge and waded toward it, holding his cameras high to protect them against the sea water. He was dragged aboard, safe.

Speeding toward England: No Time to Lose

He accompanied his film across the channel to assure its protection, then delivered it into the hands of a courier in Weymouth, England.

He knew what extraordinary images he had. He scrawled a note to editor Morris that “all the action was on the four rolls of 35 mm.” Then, he jumped the next ship back to Normandy for more images.

Life at Life

At the London headquarters, all were anxiously awaiting the film. The film (and shoes) of Life photographer Bob Landry had been lost, so Capa’s images were all they had as a record of the invasion.

35 mm film rolls, part of the D-Day invasion of Normandy, the longest day, where life's choices made a difference (Photo © snvv/iStock)

Only 11 images were saved.
© snvv/iStock

They were counting the hours until the deadline for the courier pouch to the U.S.

When Capa’s package arrived, the whole staff went into RUSH mode. The film was developed and the lab director called it “fabulous.”

Then, in the scramble to dry the film quickly for contact sheets and prints, the heat of the drying cabinet was turned up too high. The emulsion of the film melted.

Three rolls were completely ruined; but, miraculously, 11 frames on the fourth roll were salvageable—some of the most dramatic battle photos ever made. These were printed and packaged hastily for the U.S.

Morris drove like a madman to the censor and then to the courier. The traffic gods were kind. He made it, with seconds to spare.

The rest is history. The images appeared in the June 19 issue of Life for all to feel the impact and magnitude of the invasion. Morris remembers that day as one of the most important of his life.

Transport of German prisoners by American soldiers, near Saint-Lo France, after the D-Day invasion on the longest day, where life's choices made a difference (Photo © John Morris/Contact Press Images).

German prisoners transported by American soldiers near Saint-Lô in Normandy, July 1944
© John G. Morris/Contact Press Images

Liberty Does Not Come without Cost

Morris, Capa, and other war correspondents continued to document the days after the invasion, as all sides suffered heavy casualties.

These days were not, however, without reward. The French welcomed their liberators and celebrated their freedom with heartfelt gestures of thanks.

The American cemetery at Omaha Beach in Normandy, with graves of the fallen during the D-Day invasion, the longest day where life's choices made a difference. (Photo © Meredith Mullins).

The American Cemetery at Omaha Beach, a reminder of the sacrifices made for freedom
© Meredith Mullins

Oh I See

The story of D-Day and the courage and resolve of the Allied forces and war correspondents provide, for me, not so much an “Oh, I see” moment as an “I don’t want to forget” moment.

Capa’s photos serve as an important reminder that thousands of lives were lost that day and in the days to follow.

The photo of the single soldier “stands out because it humanizes the invasion,” Morris says of the iconic image.

It is one way to remember the sacrifices and life choices that were made in the name of freedom.

Robert Capa died in 1954 at age 40 when he stepped on a land mine in Indochina. His memoir, Slightly Out of Focus, was first published in 1947.

Somewhere in France, a book by John G. Morris about life after the D-Day Invasion in Normandy, the longest day where life's choices made a difference.

Somewhere in France, by John G. Morris
(Photo courtesy of Contact Press Images)

John Morris, age 97, lives in Paris and has just had his most recent book of photographs and stories published by Marabout, Quelque Part en France. His memoir Get the Picture was published by Random House in 1998.

 

 

 

 

OIC appreciates permission to use the Robert Capa photo from the International Center of Photography and Magnum Photos and permission to use the John G. Morris photos from Contact Press Images.

More information about the 70th anniversary of D-Day.

Comment on this post below, or inspire insight with your own OIC Moment here.  

Cinemagraphs Reveal Beauty In and Out of Focus

by Bruce Goldstone on April 21, 2014

A cinemagraph shows Central Park in focus through a pair of glasses, revealing the beauty of corrected and uncorrected vision. (Image © Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg)

Is clarity always best?
© Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg

Natural Vision vs. Corrected Vision

Autumn leaves flutter in and out of focus in a striking image from Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg’s series of optical animations.

The effect is enchanting. But my reaction to this poetic series is perhaps atypical.

Am I the only one who gazes at this work and sees a powerful argument for the beauty of both corrected and natural vision?

The Secret Life of Photos

Beck and Burg have captivated the web since they created a new style of animated photograph to capture the excitement of Fashion Week in New York city. They call their moving creations cinemagraphs.

A cinemagraph of Anna Wintour at a fashion show, illustrating the beauty of correct vision and natural vision. (Image © Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg)

Cinemagraphs can capture both rapid and subtle movements.
© Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg

The technique stitches together photos to create a simple but persuasive illusion of movement.

Each cinemagraph is a single compelling burst. Like the contrasting images in a fine haiku, stillness and motion battle for the viewer’s attention.

A cinemagraph of a taxi reflected in a cafe window, illustrating the beauty of corrected and natural vision. (Image © Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg)

The ghost of a taxi in a silent reflective loop.
© Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg

You can see many more examples of the impressive and flexible technique at the artists’ site, Ann Street Studio.

Sight and Insight

A pair of spiffy Giorgio Armani eyeglass frames inspired the team to create a series of cinemagraphs in and around New York City.

But what really speaks to me in these shots isn’t how perfectly they capture the hum and throb of city life.

Instead, I’m reminded of the emphatic reaction I had to my first pair of glasses, one of my earliest “Oh, I see” moments. Though, in this case, it was more of an “Oh, I won’t see” moment.

A cinemagraph of Times Square's flashing lights, illustrating the beauty of corrected and natural vision. (Image © Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg)

Times Square in and out of focus.
© Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg

I was about eleven when I got my first glasses. I hated them.

The aviator-style frames were fashionable enough for my fifth-grade aesthetic. But the glasses made me question the whole idea of corrective optometry. Sure, the world looked different. But is different always better?

I didn’t think so. I liked seeing the world my way, blurry though it was.

Each morning, I dutifully put my glasses on so my parents wouldn’t think they’d wasted their money.

A cinemagraph showing some reading The New York Times, illustrating the beauty of corrected and natural vision. (Image © Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg)

Sharpening a morning routing.
© Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg

Then at school, I’d stash them in my desk and the world would return to normal. My normal.

I was used to seeing the world in a lovely Impressionist haze, free of hard edges and crisp details. Doctors and teachers insisted that their world was a better place, but I wasn’t convinced.

I liked my world the way it was. As far as I was concerned, nothing about it needed correcting.

A cinemagraph of the New York Skyline, illustrating the beauty of corrected and natural vision. (Image © Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg)

There’s beauty in the blur.
© Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg

The magical melding of the lights on the Manhattan Bridge in this cinemagraph reminds me of how energetically I defended my right to see the world my way.

In Favor of Focus

My battle against glasses lasted the better part of a year.

Of course, eventually I gave in. There was no exact moment of defeat. It was more of a gradual acquiescence.

In the end, the benefits of seeing where you’re going became, well, apparent. And being able to read the chalkboard turned out to be helpful, too.

And by the time I got to driving, I was a firm convert to the 20/20 world.

A cinemagraph of Grand Central Station commuters, showing the beauty of corrected and natural vision. (Image © Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg)

Crisp and chaotic commuter commotion becomes an ice ballet when blurred.
© Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg

But once in a while, I still enjoy taking a vacation from focus. Without corrective lenses, the world returns to a softer, more comforting place.

Or at least that’s how it seems until I bump headfirst into something.

I’m grateful to Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg for this series of cinemagraphs, which depicts the eloquent balance between natural and corrected vision.

If you want to create your own cinemagraphs, check out this helpful tutorial.

Comment on this post below, or inspire insight with your own OIC Moment here.

Richard Renaldi Poses Strangers . . . and Questions

by Bruce Goldstone on April 7, 2014

Portrait from Richard Renaldi's Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships. (Image © Richard Renaldi).

Sonia, Zach, Raekwon, and Antonio, 2011, Tampa, FL
from Touching Strangers (Aperture, May 2014)
© Richard Renaldi

Touching Strangers Creates and Captures Fleeting Relationships

Two kids and two adults perch on a bed in an anonymous Florida hotel in Richard Renaldi’s striking photographic portrait.

Their body language shifts every time you look back. Are they relaxed or tense? Friendly or feuding? A hidden piece of information explains why the subtext is so hard to read: these people aren’t an actual family. In fact, they just met moments ago.

Renaldi’s project Touching Strangers investigates the complex chemistry of fleeting relationships. What happens when people who don’t know each other pose as friends, lovers, or family members?

Portrait from Richard Renaldi's Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships. (Image © Richard Renaldi).

Tom, Alaina, and Charlie, 2012, San Francisco, CA
from Touching Strangers (Aperture, May 2014)
© Richard Renaldi

Do appearances reflect reality? Or maybe they create it?

Sometimes When We Touch

The basics of the project are simple: Renaldi finds two or more strangers and asks them to pose together. The eloquent, complex results are on display at Aperture Gallery in New York City through May 15, 2014.

Asking strangers to assume intimate poses creates an obviously unnatural situation. Nerves and awkwardness are a common first response, and are frequently reflected in subtle body language in the final portrait.

Portrait from Richard Renaldi's Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships. (Image © Richard Renaldi).

Nathan and Robyn, 2012, Provincetown, MA
from Touching Strangers (Aperture, May 2014)
© Richard Renaldi

Yet many of the portraits create an uncanny sense of reality. How can this relationship be a put-on?

Portrait from Richard Renaldi's Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships. (Image © Richard Renaldi).

Donna and Donna, 2012, Craig, CO
from Touching Strangers (Aperture, May 2014)
© Richard Renaldi

Even though the relationship is artificially constructed, by the time Renaldi snaps the photo, the relationship may not be fake after all. This insight became an “Oh, I see” moment for both Renaldi and the participants.

Portrait from Richard Renaldi's Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships. (Image © Richard Renaldi).

Atiljan and Tiffany, 2011, New York, NY
from Touching Strangers (Aperture, May 2014)
© Richard Renaldi

Getting to Know You

Renaldi uses a large format 8-by-10-inch-view camera for his portraits, in part because he prefers the quality of the resulting images, and in part because the process itself takes time, and time creates comfort.

Portrait from Richard Renaldi's Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships. (Image © Richard Renaldi).

Tari, Shawn, and Summer, 2012, Los Angeles, CA
from Touching Strangers (Aperture, May 2014)
© Richard Renaldi

Unlike a quick digital snapshot, the large format camera requires a slower pace. While Renaldi is setting up, the subjects have time to talk and relax. By the time he begins taking pictures, some of the strangeness of the situation is already worn off.

In May, Aperture Foundation will publish Touching Strangers, a large-format book documenting the project.

In the Afterword, Renaldi shares how he began to understand the value of the slowed-down photographic process in creating space for a personal connection to take place:

“On completing one of these photographs, there was often the feeling that something rare and unrepeatable had just occurred.”

Portrait from Richard Renaldi's Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships. (Image © Richard Renaldi).

Michael and Kimberly, 2011, New York, NY
from Touching Strangers (Aperture, May 2014)
© Richard Renaldi

Stranger Things Have Happened

This video of Renaldi at work shows how his constructed poses swiftly segue from distance and discomfort into real, if temporary, relationships.

If the video does not display, watch it here.

Come Together

Renaldi delights in combining subjects from different backgrounds to create his instant families.

Portrait from Richard Renaldi's Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships. (Image © Richard Renaldi).

Vincent and Charles, 2012, Los Angeles, CA
from Touching Strangers (Aperture, May 2014)
© Richard Renaldi

The juxtapositions arouse human, and humane, questions. What’s a family, anyway?

Portrait from Richard Renaldi's Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships. (Image © Richard Renaldi).

Kiya and Simon, 2012, New York, NY
from Touching Strangers (Aperture, May 2014)
© Richard Renaldi

Which pairs are lovers? Which pairs are friends? Can you always tell the difference?

I’m a Stranger Here Myself

The Touching Strangers project has been enthusiastically received as word of mouth has spread, and, not surprisingly, a lot of people want to get involved.

Richard Renaldi, author of Touching Strangers, a project that creates and captures fleeting relationships.

The photographer who stages connections
invites others to join in.
© Richard Renaldi

Renaldi has received many requests from people who want to recreate his process and find their own Oh, I see” moments.

Now, he’s found a way to include his fans contributions. All you need is a camera and the courage to say “Hello” to some complete strangers.

Using Twitter, people who’d like to join the project can send their own pictures of strangers to hashtag #TouchingStrangers.

Richard will check the feed regularly and select favorite photos to be displayed alongside his own at the Aperture exhibit.

As the Touching Strangers project evolves, Richard Renaldi has found surprisingly rich ways to preserve the flash and spark in fleeting relationships.

Comment on this post below, or inspire insight with your own OIC Moment here.

Copyright © 2011-2025 OIC Books   |   All Rights Reserved   |   Privacy Policy