Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property GridArchives::$plugin_url is deprecated in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/grid-archives/grid-archives.php on line 55

Notice: Function _load_textdomain_just_in_time was called incorrectly. Translation loading for the heartbeat-control domain was triggered too early. This is usually an indicator for some code in the plugin or theme running too early. Translations should be loaded at the init action or later. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 6.7.0.) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6131

Warning: Constant WP_PLUGIN_URL already defined in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/ios-icons-for-wordpress/ios-icons.php on line 31

Deprecated: Function get_bloginfo was called with an argument that is deprecated since version 2.2.0! The siteurl option is deprecated for the family of bloginfo() functions. Use the url option instead. in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6131

Notice: Function _load_textdomain_just_in_time was called incorrectly. Translation loading for the media-tags domain was triggered too early. This is usually an indicator for some code in the plugin or theme running too early. Translations should be loaded at the init action or later. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 6.7.0.) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6131

Notice: Function _load_textdomain_just_in_time was called incorrectly. Translation loading for the mpress-hide-from-search domain was triggered too early. This is usually an indicator for some code in the plugin or theme running too early. Translations should be loaded at the init action or later. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 6.7.0.) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6131

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wprp_analytics::$distinct_id is deprecated in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/wordpress-23-related-posts-plugin/analytics.php on line 34

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wprp_analytics::$ip_address is deprecated in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/wordpress-23-related-posts-plugin/analytics.php on line 37

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property ConsumerStrategies_SocketConsumer::$_port is deprecated in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/wordpress-23-related-posts-plugin/mixpanel/lib/ConsumerStrategies/SocketConsumer.php on line 91

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property ConsumerStrategies_SocketConsumer::$_port is deprecated in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/wordpress-23-related-posts-plugin/mixpanel/lib/ConsumerStrategies/SocketConsumer.php on line 91

Notice: Function _load_textdomain_just_in_time was called incorrectly. Translation loading for the wptouch-pro domain was triggered too early. This is usually an indicator for some code in the plugin or theme running too early. Translations should be loaded at the init action or later. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 6.7.0.) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6131

Notice: Function _load_textdomain_just_in_time was called incorrectly. Translation loading for the esquire domain was triggered too early. This is usually an indicator for some code in the plugin or theme running too early. Translations should be loaded at the init action or later. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 6.7.0.) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6131

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/grid-archives/grid-archives.php:55) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/rest-api/class-wp-rest-server.php on line 1902

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/grid-archives/grid-archives.php:55) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/rest-api/class-wp-rest-server.php on line 1902

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/grid-archives/grid-archives.php:55) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/rest-api/class-wp-rest-server.php on line 1902

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/grid-archives/grid-archives.php:55) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/rest-api/class-wp-rest-server.php on line 1902

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/grid-archives/grid-archives.php:55) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/rest-api/class-wp-rest-server.php on line 1902

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/grid-archives/grid-archives.php:55) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/rest-api/class-wp-rest-server.php on line 1902

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$home_control in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 890

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_disable_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 897

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_disable_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 914

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$home_control in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 924

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_showall_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 927

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_showall_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 943

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$doing_reading_time in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1005

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$doing_counts in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1024

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$blocks in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1067

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$target in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1074

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$target in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1080

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$target in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1082

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property post_teaser::$full_template is deprecated in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1145

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$block_stats in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1148

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$home_control in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 890

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_disable_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 897

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_disable_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 914

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$home_control in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 924

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_showall_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 927

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_showall_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 943

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$doing_reading_time in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1005

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$doing_counts in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1024

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$blocks in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1067

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$target in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1074

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$target in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1080

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$target in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1082

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$block_stats in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1148

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$home_control in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 890

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_disable_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 897

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_disable_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 914

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$home_control in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 924

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_showall_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 927

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$use_showall_filter in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 943

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$doing_reading_time in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1005

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$doing_counts in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1024

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$blocks in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1067

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$target in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1074

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$target in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1080

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$target in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1082

Warning: Undefined property: post_teaser::$block_stats in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/post-teaser/post-teaser.php on line 1148
When four teenagers and a writer, Joyce McGreevy, meet in the Volksgarten, Vienna, Austria, they share the fun of speaking two languages. Image © Joyce McGreevy

Finding our voices in Vienna: Catrina, Cedric, the author, Nicky, and Adah. (Oh, and “Albert.”)
© Joyce McGreevy

What Four Viennese Teens Taught Me
About Speaking Two Languages

I was sitting on a park bench in Vienna when they approached me, speaking two languages.

What’s more international than the Volksgarten? An Austrian park in formal French style around a replica Greek temple, it attracts visitors from around the world.

The replica Temple of Theseus at the Volksgarten, Vienna gives a group of visitors an opportunity for speaking in two languages. (Public domain image by Norman Davies)

The Volksgarten (“people’s garden”) blooms with roses and buzzes with languages. 
Norman Davies (public domain)

I’d been thinking about language, about the surprising fact that I’d found it easier to speak Hungarian than German.

Let me explain. One of my travel pleasures is taking language lessons and then practicing every day with native speakers. Picking things up little by little. Savoring the taste of new words.

Permission to Speak

When I did this in cities like Budapest, or countries like Malta, Bulgaria, Greece, and Turkey, native speakers responded with encouragement. It’s not about ego boosting—the nearest toddler could out-debate me—but genuine human connection.

People overlooked flaws in pronunciation, eased me past mistakes, and enriched my vocabulary with the aplomb of chocolatiers proffering boxes of pralines.

Alas, when I spoke German in Austria, native speakers switched to English. Politely, but irrevocably. How to negotiate, to explain that I missed speaking two languages?

So what if I strode in one language, limped in the other? I’d happily hobble along in order to learn.

A street scene in Vienna reminds a writer of the pleasures of speaking two languages. (Image © Joyce McGreevy)

I longed to steep myself in another language to the point of dreaming in it. (Vienna)
© Joyce McGreevy

A Wanderlust for Words

I became a silent student of German. I read food labels and environmental text,  listened to opera and watched local news. At a thrift store near Sigmund Freud’s historic apartment, I found a 1970s children’s book and carried it home like it was Mozart’s lost sonata.

Whenever I rode the metro or shared an elevator, my ears fairly twitched like a dog’s toward familiar sounds.

Assorted German-language reading materials inspire a writer in Vienna who misses speaking two languages. (Image © Joyce McGreevy)

A language learner’s improvised library. 
© Joyce McGreevy

Talking Points

I marveled at close connections and vast gaps between German and English.

I fell in love with the word arbeitslust, which artist Gustav Klimt used to discuss the will, indeed the burning desire, to do one’s work.

But I wasn’t speaking two languages.

It was like viewing a feast, but never tasting it. Maybe there’s a German word for that, too.

Cakes on display in Cafe Demel, Vienna, Austria become a metaphor for speaking two languages. (Image © Joyce McGreevy)

Cakes on display at Café Demel, Vienna. The sweetness is hidden inside. 
© Joyce McGreevy

Teen Talk to the Rescue

Then I met four Austrian teens on a mission.

Their teacher had sent forth small groups with an unusual assignment: Go to the Volksgarten, find a friendly foreigner, and make a trade using English.

Their teacher was helping her students acquire language functions.

Language functions are specific purposes we address every day: We summarize a movie. We compare and contrast our baseball team’s wins and losses. We greet neighbors and ask questions to get to know them. We persuade a friend to help us move.

A market in Budapest reminds a writer of reasons for speaking two languages. (Image © Joyce McGreevy)

We negotiate everything from groceries to relationships. (Budapest)
© Joyce McGreevy

A Good Egg

“What are you trading?” I asked.

“Albert,” they said.

“Excuse me?”

Albert, it turned out, was a total egghead. Hard-boiled, I was assured.

Cedric, Catriona, Adah, and Nicky persuaded me that I would benefit from the trade, because:

Sure, they might have mentioned that eggs are a reliable source of protein, selenium, and vitamin D. But when the egg in question has a big goofy smile, why go there?

For my negotiation, all I had was a pen. So I told stories about, well, writing stories with it.

And since negotiations entailed that all stakeholders should benefit, I suggested they each use the pen to record English expressions.

“It’s a deal!”

A deal that got sweeter: The teens spoke German with me. Vielen Dank!

People conversing near water in Vienna, Austria become a metaphor for speaking two languages. (Image © Joyce McGreevy)

Languages reflect our universal impulse to connect.  (Vienna)
© Joyce McGreevy

Trading Ideas

We traded pleasantries and then we traded languages. Like ei for “egg.” And glücklich for “happy.”

Ich bin glücklich, I ventured.

“We’re happy, too,” they said. “This was fun!” When four teens say they’ve enjoyed meeting a woman old enough to be their grandm—uh, mom, that’s a good day.

Suddenly, it didn’t matter who was the native speaker. Only that we were speaking. In two languages.

These confident-looking teens admitted they’d felt nervous approaching strangers to start a conversation. Some folks shooed them away.

As for the trade, anyone who’d been willing to negotiate offered . . . a pen. So why had they accepted mine?

You made it into a story,” they said.  “What about us?”

“You made an egg into ‘Albert.’ An ei into an I.”

An egg character set against a scene of urban crowds becomes a metaphor for the fragility one can feel when speaking two languages. (Image © Joyce McGreevy)

Feel fragile when speaking two languages? C’mon out of your shell!
© Joyce McGreevy

Oh, I see: We’re all speaking two languages. Words, and whatever gives them meaning. Imagination and negotiation. Curiosity and discovery. Trust and connection.

Is there a word that means “a love of communicating with others”? With practice—and the encouragement of fellow travelers—we just might find out.

Comment on this post below, or inspire insight with your own OIC Moment here.


Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/grid-archives/grid-archives.php:55) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/rest-api/class-wp-rest-server.php on line 1902

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-content/plugins/grid-archives/grid-archives.php:55) in /home1/genwebsi/public_html/ohisee/blog/wp-includes/rest-api/class-wp-rest-server.php on line 1902
{"id":29599,"date":"2017-10-24T03:00:24","date_gmt":"2017-10-24T10:00:24","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/ohisee.genweb.site\/blog\/?p=29599"},"modified":"2021-07-20T08:02:30","modified_gmt":"2021-07-20T15:02:30","slug":"the-egg-and-ei","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.oh-i-see.com\/blog\/the-egg-and-ei\/","title":{"rendered":"The Egg and \u201cEi\u201d"},"content":{"rendered":"
\"When

Finding our voices in Vienna: Catrina, Cedric, the author, Nicky, and Adah. (Oh, and “Albert.”)
\u00a9 Joyce McGreevy<\/p><\/div>\n

What Four Viennese Teens Taught Me
About Speaking Two Languages<\/strong><\/h2>\n

I was sitting on a park bench in Vienna when they approached me, speaking two languages.<\/p>\n

What’s more international than the Volksgarten? An Austrian park in formal French style around a replica Greek temple, it attracts visitors from around the world.<\/p>\n

\"The

The Volksgarten (“people’s garden”) blooms with roses and buzzes with languages.\u00a0
Norman Davies (public domain)<\/p><\/div>\n

I’d been thinking about language, about the surprising fact that I’d found it easier to speak Hungarian than German.<\/p>\n

Let me explain. One of my travel pleasures is taking language lessons and then practicing every day with native speakers. Picking things up little by little. Savoring the taste of new words.<\/p>\n

Permission to Speak<\/h4>\n

When I did this in cities like Budapest, or countries like Malta, Bulgaria, Greece, and Turkey, native speakers responded with encouragement. It\u2019s not about ego boosting\u2014the nearest toddler could out-debate me\u2014but genuine human connection.<\/p>\n

People overlooked flaws in pronunciation, eased me past mistakes, and enriched my vocabulary with the aplomb of chocolatiers proffering boxes of pralines.<\/p>\n

Alas, when I spoke German in Austria, native speakers switched to English. Politely, but irrevocably. How to negotiate, to explain that I missed<\/em> speaking two languages?<\/p>\n

So what if I strode in one language, limped in the other? I\u2019d happily hobble along in order to learn.<\/p>\n

\"A

I longed to steep myself in another language to the point of dreaming in it. (Vienna)
\u00a9 Joyce McGreevy<\/p><\/div>\n

A Wanderlust for Words<\/h4>\n

I became a silent student of German. I read food labels and environmental text, \u00a0listened to opera and watched local news. At a thrift store near Sigmund Freud\u2019s historic apartment,\u00a0I found a 1970s children\u2019s book and carried it home like it was Mozart’s lost sonata.<\/p>\n

Whenever I rode the metro or shared an elevator, my ears fairly twitched like a dog’s toward familiar sounds.<\/p>\n

\"Assorted

A language learner’s improvised library.\u00a0
\u00a9 Joyce McGreevy<\/p><\/div>\n

Talking Points<\/h4>\n

I marveled at close connections and vast gaps between German and English.<\/p>\n

I fell in love with the word arbeitslust, <\/em>which\u00a0<\/em>artist Gustav Klimt used to discuss the will, indeed the burning desire, to do one\u2019s work.<\/p>\n

But I wasn\u2019t speaking<\/em> two languages.<\/p>\n

It was like viewing a feast, but never tasting it. Maybe there\u2019s a German word for that, too.<\/p>\n

\"Cakes

Cakes on display at Caf\u00e9 Demel, Vienna. The sweetness is hidden inside.\u00a0
\u00a9 Joyce McGreevy<\/p><\/div>\n

Teen Talk to the Rescue<\/h4>\n

Then I met four Austrian teens on a mission.<\/p>\n

Their teacher had sent forth small groups with an unusual assignment: Go to the Volksgarten, find a friendly foreigner, and make a trade using English.<\/p>\n

Their teacher was helping her students acquire language functions<\/strong>.<\/p>\n

Language functions are specific purposes we address every day: We summarize<\/strong> a movie. We compare and contrast<\/strong> our baseball team\u2019s wins and losses. We greet<\/strong> neighbors and ask questions<\/strong> to get to know them. We persuade<\/strong> a friend to help us move.<\/p>\n

\"A

We\u00a0negotiate<\/strong>\u00a0everything from groceries to relationships. (Budapest)
\u00a9 Joyce McGreevy<\/p><\/div>\n

A Good Egg<\/h4>\n

\u201cWhat are you trading?\u201d I asked.<\/p>\n

\u201cAlbert,\u201d they said.<\/p>\n

\u201cExcuse me?\u201d<\/p>\n

Albert, it turned out, was a total egghead. Hard-boiled, I was assured.<\/p>\n

Cedric, Catriona, Adah, and Nicky persuaded me that I would benefit from the trade, because:<\/p>\n